.
Feedback

Letter to the Editor: Macdonald on Arts on the Waterfront

Mayoral candidate Andrew Macdonald says he is not opposed to the idea of a Corcoran Gallery of Art coming to the waterfront, but the idea must be vetted first.

Dear Editor: 

Alexandria has a thriving arts community, and we should support it at every opportunity, in all parts of the City.

Citizens for an Alternative Alexandria Waterfront Plan (CAAWP) argued that the arts would do more to open up the waterfront to public use then a big hotel, more town homes, condos or offices. Indeed, the CAAWP plan, while not perfect, pointed out how arts and history venues might bring life to parts of the waterfront that currently are private for the most part. They also recommended keeping the Art League on the waterfront.

I include in that broad category of “waterfront for all” organizations like the Alexandria Seaport Foundation, which hosted a lovely waterfront fundraiser on Sunday that will benefit their youth apprenticeship program.

I’m not opposed to the Corcoran , if that makes sense for them, but just because it’s a great art institution does not automatically make it right for Alexandria or its waterfront. What we should want, I think, is to tie good ideas with good planning, in order to make certain that such projects will fund our City’s quality of life in a sustainable fashion.

My mother was a fine artist, and I ran an art gallery along the waterfront for a time. Make no mistake about it: I will support the arts if elected as your next mayor, but not projects that just sound like a good idea and have not been screened by the community first.

Andrew Macdonald

 

Andrew Macdonald is running as an independent to be mayor of Alexandria.

Gina Baum June 11, 2012 at 01:15 pm
One word Hypocrit -- develops his own waterfront plan which includes a focus on museums, because lets face it folks, Andrew Macdonald, is above all an expert planner (sarcasm) far beyond any of the well educated professionals who have dedicated their lives to making Alexandria a better place to live...then at the mere rumor of the Corcoran considering a move with Alexandria being considered a far off possibility, he has a knee JERK reaction to oppose it (I'm sure since he is flip flopping he took down his patch posts against it) whatever...
JT Thomas June 11, 2012 at 01:36 pm
Andrew, thanks for calling attention away from the scandal with the Alexandria Democrats. It's gotten so underhanded over there, maybe you should rejoin the party.
Walt L June 11, 2012 at 03:02 pm
Wow, Andrew. The idea needs to be vetted? I bet no one else would have ever thought of that. This was a little thin, but way to get free press. Keep these letters coming so voters can be reminded of the issues you care about (waterfront CAAWP waterfront CAAWP waterfront) and what you would bring to the table if elected.
cwer June 11, 2012 at 03:37 pm
No doubt the Corcoran will be thrilled to hear that Mr. Macdonald is not opposed to them coming to Alexandria. I’m sure everyone there was on hold awaiting his blessing. After all, he ran an art gallery. He forgot to mention how it compared in size to the Corcoran. Maybe that will be his next effort at free publicity. Oh hang on Macdonald always wants the community to screen things first. 150,000 will now get out their yes/no remote buttons and Macdonald will go with whatever gets the most votes. Wasn’t CAAWP concerned about traffic on the waterfront? I wonder if the Corcoran would draw any. Let’s screen the community to see.
Walt L June 11, 2012 at 04:00 pm
cwer, you have a great idea. Mayor Macdonald can set up a "text your vote" system so we can settle everything by referendum. Each vote costs 99 cents, which will become revenue for the city. The more issues, and the greater the participation, the higher the revenue. A Facebook page and Twitter account will be needed to notify citizens throughout the day as new referenda are introduced.
donotpaveparadise June 11, 2012 at 07:34 pm
No matter what is proposed for the waterfront, we need to be sure that there is good planning in advance, and that it is appropriate to Alexandria's waterfront. Mr. Macdonald is saying that we need proper planning before we approve something. It would be very smart to find out whether the Corcoran will actually fit on the waterfront. We would have to do in depth studies of whether a densely crowded urban area like Alexandria, which is already besieged by traffic problems, could bear the traffic this kind of museum would bring.
spff spaceman June 11, 2012 at 07:40 pm
who are the developers that want to develop the waterfront anyway and who did they give money to?
Kim Moore June 12, 2012 at 08:34 pm
All of the discussions about development really interest me. I recall the heated debates 20 years ago when Potomac Yard was a proposed site for the Redskins Stadium. Residents shot that down based on environmental and traffic concerns.
Now, instead of 8 weeks of traffic (not including special events), Potomac Yards gets enormous retail traffic, and the environmental concerns seem to have been resolved enough to allow for THOUSANDS of homes. Did we get the raw end of that deal? I am not saying that I would have preferred a stadium, but what have learned from that project's 20-20 hindsight?
Jim Ward June 13, 2012 at 03:19 pm
Potomac Yards gets enormous retail traffic, and THOUSANDS of homes. As a taxpayer, I'm happy for Alexandria. I would welcome the Corcoran, but that ain't gonna happen.
Ruben Duran June 14, 2012 at 06:16 pm
Arts, arts, arts, many a times it seems that the city gets more caught up on the Arts, then our school needs, traffic/road improvements. Visit Santa Barbara, Ca on a Sunday when they have their "Sidewalk Arts Thing" along the beach Memorial Day to Labor Day. Figure out how to mirror that along the Potomac when you AMUSEMENT PARK it. It would bring a traffic nightmare, but it would also keep King Street open. And trying to put offices on the first floor of the Torpedoe Factory, that should have been done when it was built, before all the hotels opened up. Doing it now is idiotic. Where is the real short-term and long-term planning for this city.
Ruben Duran June 14, 2012 at 08:47 pm
Further wouldn't it be a smarter move for the Corcoran to relocate to what will become the new Landmark Center with it's new planned housing and office building. I am assuming Sears and Macy's are staying as well. One would think that it would help to revitalize the West End. Ah, but yes, City Hall and several council members only truly care about Old Town and Del Ray. Your actions speak louder than your words.

Newsletter & Alerts

Get the best stories each day and important breaking news

Subscribe

Not from Old Town Alexandria Patch? Find your Local Patch »

Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors. Write a new post... What's up? Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell something
Bea Porter May 22, 2013 at 02:38 pm
Very well said. A new building will not bring up the test scores, and its not the fault of theRead More parents. Dr. Sherman changes staff so frequently it makes sense that the scores are not improving. Jefferson-Houston needs to have consistency in staff, and not the turnovers that it has had in the last several years. These students can achieve, they can do well, but they need to have consistent structure, and teachers that are willing to teach them in the manner they can learn best. Take these 350 students and reintegrate them into other schools that are achieving, then see them rise as the stars they are. Stop keeping them segregated, stop the under achievement. Stop this new building.
Lee Hernly May 22, 2013 at 03:21 pm
While I agree with the commenters and the writer on their comments, I do suggest that, if you haveRead More not done so already, do take a tour of the school to see the changes taking place. It's hard to see how the kids can learn anything there at the school given the current open classroom environment. Having lived here all my life, I seem to recall as well that at one point in time, Lyles Crouch was in a similar situation like Jefferson Houston currently is. Lyles Crouch has turned itself around so who's to say that Jefferson Houston won't? Dr. Sherman though, needs to go.
Foo Bar May 25, 2013 at 04:33 pm
As I remember, Lyles-Crouch did not bootstrap itself but got help from Herb Berg, the superintendentRead More before Rebecca Parry. In the '99 redistricting he rezoned Lyles-Crouch's attendance area so that a number of disadvantaged kids who formerly went there now go to Jefferson-Houston.
Jon Rosenbaum May 23, 2013 at 03:10 pm
I find myself agreeing with the writer for once. This is a quality of life and security issue.Read More Actually 60 lights were out a few months ago from the river to the Metro station. TE&S does a survey only once a year. Otherwise its Director says it is up to citizens to report lights that are out. I report light outages on my block, but it is unreasonable to expect citizens to report each light number out on a commercial street. Then there is the issue of repair time. Last fall it took three months to repair a damaged light in the 100 block of N. Saint Asaph Street.
Defy Libtards May 23, 2013 at 03:49 pm
The city is sooooooooooooo boring. Why can't we just continue with the Hippie v. ConservativeRead More bashing; it's been too long since somebody has called me a (racist) because I like small government.
Scot May 23, 2013 at 03:57 pm
Not enough anger in this op ed, please revise. Clap*Clap*Clap Also, why is everyone typing when weRead More could all be out robbing banks? Apparently it is the new cool "thing" in Alexandria.
Sherry Henderson April 30, 2013 at 02:43 pm
Gail, I would say that past elected officials have been very much to blame for the problems with theRead More Alexandria City Public School system, especially the old regime who mismanaged the administration of those schools for the past few years. One can say that they most certainly weren't 'the brightest bulbs in the box'. But the honeymoon is over for the current Alexandria School Board and the Alexandria City Council to grab the bull by the horns and work to solidly fix Alexandria City Public Schools. I understand that a very small percentage of families in Alexandria have children, as the city is geared to newlyweds or people who either don't want or can't afford to have children. Many people move out of Alexandria by the time their children reach the age to go to school because of the low scores that Alexandria City Public Schools have in comparison to great schools in both neighboring Fairfax and Arlington Counties. Getting back to your comment that there are 'entrenched administrators', they need to be publicly outed for their incompetence and sent packing. It amazes me how many elected officials boast how great it is to live in the City of Alexandria, yet they have a glaring problem with Alexandria City Public Schools and are seemingly incompetent to fix them. This isn't a political issue, but as a Democrat, I'm very embarrassed by, as I've noted, the 'good ole boy' and 'good ole girl', wink-wink, back-scratching politics that go on in Alexandria City Hall. Disgusting.
Gail April 30, 2013 at 03:31 pm
We have an almost entirely brand new school board. They were stuck with a big mess. They were onlyRead More installed four months ago. Give them some time. This won't be easy. They are hampered by budget issues right now, existing contracts, etc. These new comers are NOT part of the "ole boy/girl" network. Karen Graaf, Patricia Hennig and Bill Campbell are NOT the "old network" at all. Kelly Carmichael Booz and Chris Lewis were politically active in the city but they are also most definitely NOT part of the "old" network. Marc Williams is the leftover from those days and for reasons I don't understand, he is very popular with parents in the George Mason district where he lives. Sherman has been a disaster, but the fact is that his hiring was actually spearheaded by former school board chair Yvonne Folkerts, who is a Republican. The Dems did not create that particular monster but we were somewhat responsible for allowing the monster to eat the city. I've been screaming for his firing since 2008 and there is a nice bottle of champagne chilling in my fridge for the day he gets his walking papers.
Sherry Henderson April 30, 2013 at 04:25 pm
The Alexandria City Council, except for our great Vice Mayor, Allison Silberberg, is definitely allRead More run by the very entrenched 'good ole boy' and 'good old girl' network that has completely strangled Alexandria politics for years. Many Democrats that I know are completely turned off by our local elected officials, who, despite their good intentions, continuously embarrass us by their votes and misconstrued thoughts that they're doing something right for the future of our city. Alexandria is the true 'banana republic' of D.C. area politics, because those who, uhm, 'govern' us have a "see no evil, hear no evil, and speak no evil" mantra to themselves, especially Justin Wilson, who loves to overly pontificate as he drones on until he foams at the mouth during his lengthy dissertations that are as mindless as he is. And Justin, and the rest of the politburo that we have seated at Alexandria City Hall are hell bent to run the city any way they like. As a Democrat, I know that we can sure do better than what we've got in office now, and there are a ton of great forward-thinking progressives who would be much better than the stooges who are in Alexandria City Hall now, but the 'political elite' throws up obstacles to keep themselves in power. That in itself is very shameful, but since the City of Alexandria is so 'provincial' in its 'my way or the highway' governance, we're always doomed to inefficiency in comparison to Fairfax and Arlington Counties. We definitely deserve better.
Dan Sehnal April 24, 2013 at 06:34 pm
46 pounds per household sounds like a lot per household. It would be interesting to know where theRead More number came from and how it was computed. Although anecdotal, a quick inspection of the 26 homes on our street in old town, I would guess we are talking about 10-15 pounds per household. That's a big differential. Is business and/or industrial waste included in that number? If so, I can better understand. Thanks, D. Sehnal Quay St.
Michael Clem April 25, 2013 at 02:30 pm
The 46 pounds per household is somewhat inflated because it includes weight from Alexandria'sRead More schools and City government buildings. But the number is not that far off. The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency estimates that an average household generates 1.2 tons of trash a year. That's about 46 lbs. a week. People who recycle all that they can and do not have much yard waste will generate much less. You must be one of those households. Great job!
Nate McKenzie April 30, 2013 at 05:45 pm
Michael, What is your opinion of municipal composting programs? Would a municipal compostingRead More program make sense in Alexandria (not sure of benefits when we are already incinerating)? Can municipal composting be cost effective for us? Thanks, Nate
Concerned Virginian April 23, 2013 at 02:17 am
OldTowner, The city may be compare its pay/benefits with other jurisdictions, but that doesn't meanRead More they do anything to make them more fair and equitable. I provided a detailed comparison of Alexandria Police and a neighboring county, one full of facts and actual logic. I notice you didn't respond. You probably finally realized that your statements are incorrect and, to date, have not been based on research and facts. Where is your response? Then there is your "intangibles" and the city tends to be "Safer" than others. Tell that to the officer who was maliciously wounded by an ex-convict on Christmas day. Tell that to the officers who were fired at near police headquarters and had to return fire, mortally wounding someone. Tell that to the officer who got shot in the head. Here's an idea--Don't post anymore unless you have something factual and correct to say. Let's try that.
oldtowner April 24, 2013 at 10:14 pm
to Concerned: So get a job somewhere else if you don't like working in Alexandria. I certainlyRead More value the services of our police and fire employees....I also value the services of many other city employees. Regarding the incident on Duke Street, no report on the incident has been released, so we really don't know who fired first....Most assume the deceased did, but we really don't know. Our police dept is not well-known for releasing details about incidents. And all hope for the best recovery for Ofc Laboy. His unfortunate injury has nothing to do with the pay Alexandria officers receive. You really haven't added anything of value to the conversation. Everybody always wants to be paid more and have better benefits (that they don't have to pay for); that's a fact of life everywhere.
Concerned Virginian April 29, 2013 at 02:15 am
Oldtowner, I love working in and for Alexandria, but I will also fight for fairness and equity. AndRead More I will continue to counter people like you who intentionally make incorrect statements. You say I haven't added anything of value to the conversation? I have provided hard statistics as well as anecdotal evidence to back up my claims. All you have said is "Go check your facts. I haven't had time to do research myself, but will". It is you that haven't added anything valuable. I'm still waiting for a fact-based (I know, a shocker for you) response to the salary information I provided regarding us and Arlington. What have YOU added to this conversation? (Hint--your false statements and incorrect opinions aren't valuable)
OT insider April 4, 2013 at 01:22 am
This is simple... 1. The city should withdrawl from the BZA apppeal. 2. Any further litigationRead More against the city based on a super-majority WFP vote should be dismissed - the re-vote took care of that. It's time to stop the BS, end the delay tactics and start making real progress on finally improving our embarasing, ghetto waterfront.
Haunches April 7, 2013 at 01:56 pm
The decision was made in a closed executive session to pursue these policies. That is anRead More inescapable fact. Winning an election does not mean you are now unaccountable. The news in the last few days of a jury verdict substantiating the city retaliated against an employee to protect a developer underscores the author's point.
oldtowner April 11, 2013 at 07:01 pm
to Haunches....I think VA law requires legal issues to be considered in executive session...checkRead More your facts....this has always been the case...there are a few issues that they have to consider in executive session......this fact is totally unrelated to the recent case involving a terminated City employee....can't compare apples and oranges....